We
were all set. Bret Favre announced his
retirement early, setting the table for a relatively drama-free off
season. Incessant updates of "will
he or won't he" would be gone and we could simply focus on free agent
signings and the impending draft.
Not
so fast.
The
Broncos stepped up and did their best to provide football writers with enough
material to rival any soap opera.
First,
in a surprising move, owner Pat Bowlen fired Mike Shanahan after a 14-year
tenure. After initial success, the team
struggled over the past few years forcing Bowlen to make a difficult and
emotional decision. Franchise
quarterback Jay Cutler was upset over the dismissal saying, "I'm
disappointed. I'm not happy." You
can easily infer the bond between Cutler and Shananhan, so the anger was an
appropriate and completely human reaction.
Enter
Josh McDaniels. A 32-year old former
Patriots offensive coordinator with a reputation for running a high-octane
system. Cutler began to warm up to the
scenario, perhaps realizing the benefits surrounding McDaniels' offensive
schemes. After all, look at what he
accomplished with Matt Cassel.
Cassel
barely played over the past several years, but emerged as a legit fantasy
quarterback once Tom Brady went down for the year. New England slapped the franchise tag on him, committing
themselves to 14 million dollars for the 2009 season. It was a very expensive insurance policy in case Tom Brady
couldn’t return. Apparently convinced
of Tom Brady's health, the Patriots put Cassel on the trading block and
eventually sent him along with Mike Vrabel to the Chiefs for a second-round
pick.
However,
word got out that Josh McDaniels made a major play to trade for Cassell. They had a preexisting relationship and
McDaniels decided that the Broncos would be better off with Cassell as their
leader.
As
you can imagine, that didn't sit too well with Cutler. "I'm upset. I mean
I'm really shocked at this point."
The
combination of a young and immature quarterback clashing with a young and
inexperienced head coach was bound to be volatile. Throw in seedy comments from agent Bus Cook, and the relationship
had no chance of being repaired. Cutler
rebuffed pleas from McDaniels and Bowlen to meet and discuss the issues at
hand, instead opting for a trade demand.
The
Broncos promptly entertained offers deciding on a package from the Chicago
Bears. Denver would receive first round
picks in 2009 and 2010 along with a fourth-rounder and Kyle Orton. The Bears get Cutler, and the franchise QB
they have lacked for decades.
The
prevailing opinion is Brandon Marshall and Eddie Royal won't perform as well
with Orton at quarterback. Orton simply
doesn't have a comparable arm to Cutler, so the numbers should dip. He is a QB2 with flashes of QB1 potential;
he's not established enough to be relied upon as your every-week starter. On the other side of the coin, Cutler's new
receivers aren't as talented as Marshall and Royal. Devin Hester and Earl Bennett receive a tick up in value, but
Cutler's worth is almost the same - if not slightly worse.
The
biggest benefactor in the whole debacle is Matt Forte. He carried the ball 316 times in 2008 after
361 attempts in his last year at Tulane.
With Cutler in the picture, Forte doesn’t have to carry the work load as
much. Defenses have to respect the
passing game and spread their attention, which gives Forte more room to run.
Will
they all live happily ever after? Only
time will tell…..