1 Joe Mauer - MIN
We
all were worried about Mauer’s back ailment that sidelined him for all of
April. He quickly put to rest fears
when he returned to promptly hit 11 HRs with a .414 AVE in May. He’s always been a threat in the batting
average category, but where did all that power come from? He averaged just over
4 HRs per month for the rest of the season, which may be more indicative of
where his power stroke has landed. Look
for the same stellar average and keep expectations in check – 15 to 20 HRs would
be great.
2 Victor Martinez - BOS
V-Mart
will be behind the dish most often, but he’ll get his fair share of time at
first base (and maybe even DH) throughout the year. What’s the point? – his bat is too valuable to have out of the
lineup, but Boston has to be careful not to burn him out. A full season in Fenway Park with a
tremendously better lineup around him should produce some awfully lofty numbers
for the pending free agent.
3 Brian McCann - ATL
McCann
experienced “blurry vision” which caused him to miss most of April. He came back on a tear batting .318 over the
next 3 months – apparently, the doctor outfitted him with Superman’s
glasses. He had laser eye surgery
during the off season so we’re confident the issues are behind him. He’s certainly the top NL catcher and is
easily the number 3 backstop off the board after Mauer and Martinez.
4 Matt Wieters - BAL
Sometimes
hyped fantasy prospects don’t quite live up to their billing, but that’s not
the case with Wieters. He was up and
down in the average category during his last 4 months of service, .257, .323, .250, .362, but he still managed to land at a .288
season mark. Baltimore plans on
exposing him to about 140 games, so he’s not quite ready for full time duty
yet. That doesn’t mean his production
won’t come in handy for the upcoming season.
5 Jorge Posada - NYY
He's
old. He's injury prone. But, he's still a player with pop and catcher
eligibility. He sports a career ratio
of 1 HR per 22 ABs, which isn’t too shabby for a catcher. But, there's no way Posada will get away
with a full season unscathed, so you'll certainly be trolling the waiver wire
at some point if you draft him. Nevertheless, a small ballpark, a history of
power, and a strong lineup dictate fantasy respect.
6 Kurt Suzuki - OAK
Suzuki
more than doubled his HR and RBI production with only 40 more at-bats. Although his OBP dropped from .346 to .313,
it was certainly a successful season for the A’s backstop. A .270 average and low double-digit homerun
totals are reasonable. However, playing
Oakland Coliseum will hinder his ability to improve on the 15 HR-88 RBI line he
posted last year.
7 Miguel Montero - ARI
Chris
Snyder's injury woes certainly helped, but the Diamondbacks simply couldn't
ignore his production. He blossomed,
finishing at a .294-16-59 line and he enters 2010 as the unquestioned
starter. We like the ballpark, we like
the lineup, we think he’ll finish at .275-15-70.
8 Bengie Molina - SF
Bengie
Molina’s return to the San Francisco Giants was one of the biggest free agent
surprises. After a 20-HR season and
with Buster Posey on the verge of cracking the roster, it was almost a foregone
conclusion that Molina would land a lucrative free agent contract elsewhere. The market was soft and the Giants were more
than willing to bring him back. Molina
will likely be slotted in the 6th slot instead of batting cleanup and Posey
isn't going away, so you'll likely see a decline in production. But, we think he can be a low-end option in
mixed leagues for at least part of the season.
9 Mike Napoli - LAA
Unfortunately,
“real” managers like Mike Scioscia have very little pity on us
fantasy-types. Although, Napoli has
produced consistent offensive results, Scioscia values a platoon with the more
defensively competent Jeff Mathis.
Napoli’s splits are decent, amassing a .253 AVE with 14 HRs vs. lefties
and a .330 AVE with 6 HRs vs. righties, so he might see a little time at DH,
but there’s no indication that he will receive more playing time in 2010.
10 Ryan Doumit - PIT
Doumit
is a bit of Posada-Light. He certainly
has the potential to post outstanding numbers when healthy – but he’s rarely
ever 100%. Doumit will likely be
someone’s starting mixed league catcher, just make sure to have a list of free
agent catchers handy.